While Avengers continued to soar, Battleship was shot. The pricey action war flick opened to a stale $25.5 million, averaging $6,920 from around 6,100 screens at 3,690 theaters. That was far below expectations, as distributor Universal Pictures had modestly projected a $35-$40 million opening, and it couldn't even come close to that. While competition was imminent, perhaps the main reason why the film failed to earn a big audience was because the film had some negative buzz from the marketing, and the fact it looked very much different from its' board game basis. The film even fell short of Wrath of the Titans and John Carter's dismal openings. After having an outstanding first quarter, Universal's 100th year of film business suffered its' first loss as the films' budget was a huge $209 million (according to analysts). One positive note keeping this just barely above waters is that the film has earned nearly $250 million overseas as Universal opened it in foreign markets five weeks in advance of its' domestic debut. Critical reception was negative, while audiences were slightly more positive ("B" CinemaScore).
After its' underwhelming start last weekend, Dark Shadows flinched. The film dropped 58% from last weekend to $12.6 million, for a slow $50.7 million tally in 10 days, against a budget of at least $125 million. The Tim Burton-Johnny Depp collaboration did earn a solid $30 million overseas this weekend, bringing its' two-week overseas total to over $80 million and its' worldwide total to $132 million.
Meanwhile, the final new release, What To Expect When You're Expecting, failed in its' attempt to counter-program Avengers and Battleship. The book adaptation earned $10.5 million on its' debut, for a per-theater average of a mild $3,491 from around 3,500 screens at 3,021 theaters. That was less than half of Bridesmaids opening, and was about half of what analysts were expecting. Distributor Lionsgate had forecasted a high-teens millions opening, and had produced the film for $40 million. At best, the film was close to matching the start of star Jennifer Lopez's previous film The Back-Up Plan ($12 million). Critics were negative towards this, and audiences were mixed ("B-" CinemaScore). Though the lack of female competition next weekend should help this one hold well and get notable numbers over the extended period, this one will likely be the second straight misfire for Lionsgate (after Safe).
The rest of the Top 10 wasn't nearly as impressive. The Best Exotic Marigold Hotel benefited from solid word-of-mouth, as the limited release was up 21% from last weekend to $3.2 million, averaging the best per-theater average of all films this weekend, an excellent $18,200 from just 178 theaters. The film could end up playing similarly to last year's Midnight in Paris.
The Hunger Games spent a ninth weekend in the Top 10, and slid just 35% from last weekend to $2.95 million, for a 63-day tally of a strong $391.6 million and slotting in seventh place.. With an extended weekend coming up, the blockbuster may just have a shot at closing at $400 million. Another hit (on a smaller scale), Think Like A Man, followed with a 54% drop to eighth place and $2.65 million for a $85.8 million tally in one month of release. The Lucky One dropped 57% to $1.8 million, for a $56.9 million tally in the same amount of timeand The Pirates! Band of Misfits rounded out the Top 10 in its' fourth weekend, down 50% to $1.6 million, for a forgettable $25.5 million in 24 days.
Overall box office was down 15% from last year when Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides topped the box office with a less-than-expected $90.15 million. The fourquel in the hit series would go on to earn $240 million domestically, which was the least-grossing installment of the franchise. But, the film was a blockbuster overseas, earning $1.08 billion worldwide, charting as the eighth-biggest movie of all-time and the third-biggest movie of 2012. Bridesmaids held onto the second spot, down just 20% to $20.9 million, while Thor was down 56% to third place and $15.5 million. Fast Five and Priest rounded out the Top 10, down 48% and 68% to $10.6 million and $4.75 million.