Rating: Grade: A-
Score: 8.2/10
Family-Friendliness Scale: Level 5 (Recommended)
Kids ages 5+
You'd sacrifice anything for a dog. That's exactly what Marty would do.
Based on the best-selling books by Phyllis Reynolds Naylor, a film was made in 1995. Shiloh tells the story of a orphan beagle puppy who runs away from a mean hunter named Judd Travers, and follows 10-year old Marty Preston home. After finding the dog, Marty tries to protect him, though his parents have financial issues and Judd is their next door neighbor....
Positive Notes
Shiloh is filled with positive messages on standing up for what you believe is right, never-giving up, bravery, self-sacrifice, and self-awareness. Marty would do anything to protect Shiloh, and he works to earn his own money without complaining. It boasts a strong cast that includes the late great Rod Steiger, Michael Morairty, Scott Wilson, Bonnie Bartlett, and Blake Heron, who plays Marty, is the main standout.
The script is very well-written and actually is, pretty thoughtful. It gives us enough time to get to know the characters and at the same time, lets us know that life can have its' tragic bumps in the road. Even with all of that in focus, in terms of how faithful to its' book basis it is, I have to say, its' very faithful.
Negative Notes
The character of Judd Travers and the way he acts may appear threatening for very young kids. We see him torment his dogs, be unfair to people, and drink beer briefly. Strongest dialogue is one exclamation each of "jeez" and "I'll be danged". Even though he's trying to protect the dog he loves, Marty still lies to his parents.
Conclusion
What can I say? We don't normally see any true-blue, heartwarming and clean family movies anymore, and even though its' nearly two decades old, this charming adaptation still shines and most importantly, keeps its' focus on the family. Shiloh definitely illustrates what the book was meant for, a great movie that boasts strong messages and great role models for children.
