Overall Thoughts: Not as interesting as the first one, but still manages to charm.
The first Stargirl movie came out as the pandemic was starting. As a teenage-focused movie, it felt like a movie aimed for the age group, and yet had an "old soul" sensibility about it. It was a gentle, intimate, yet wholesome look at high school life and peer pressure. And, of course, the main character was brought to life with grace and maturity by Grace Vanderwaal.
Upon learning of the sequel's plot, I was concerned not only that the story would lose its sense of "old school" soul, but also would fall into the generic "chase your dreams" story. Especially since it's not even based on the second book in the series at all. Thankfully, the first issue never happens. As for the second, it does manage follow the "chase your dreams" narrative (and falls into a few of those cliches), but it manages to still deliver it in an entertaining and personable fashion.
VanderWaal remains genuine and sincere as Stargirl, bringing her best qualities with wit and wisdom. Judy Greer has some strong moments as her Mom, Ana. Meanwhile, Uma Thurman and Judd Hirsch both do nicely as heart-hardened supporting characters who are helped tremendously by our lead. Elijah Richardson and Tyrel Jackson Williams are solid as Stargirl's new friends, Evan and Tyrell.
As for the music, the original songs are very solid (including "Figure it Out"). The cinematography (by Bryce Fortner) and scenery are all nicely-done, with a mix of close-ups along with some nice displays of the best of LA and California. And the script subtly touches on a few mature issues (including workplace harrassment) in a way that stays honest and real without going too far or too mature for younger audiences.
On the downside, the film does conclude a little on the corny and forced side. The resolution of the film's final conflict is handled a little bit sloppily. And also, I have to point out that the film's treatment of "reaching your dreams" (especially in filmmaking as shown here) is a little sanitized and a little on the unrealistic side.
That being said, Hollywood Stargirl is still a super charming sequel. What it lacks in uniqueness and interesting elements, it makes up for some in its inviting feel and overwhelming sense of wholesome sincerity.
And it's the kind of positive, subtle, sincere film I hope we see more of for teenagers and families.
Grade: B+
Is this movie family-friendly? Hollywood Stargirl is rated PG for "some mild language". It earns the rating for one use of "d***!" and three uses of "G**!" Other than that, there's not much. We see a few low-cut outfits. We hear about directors being jerks and "investigations" conducted against them (though not in detail). One character lies. Alcoholic beverages are served at a nightclub, and those under 21 are not permitted in a "drinking section". In the end, this is a fine choice for ages 9 and up.
Is this movie family-friendly? Hollywood Stargirl is rated PG for "some mild language". It earns the rating for one use of "d***!" and three uses of "G**!" Other than that, there's not much. We see a few low-cut outfits. We hear about directors being jerks and "investigations" conducted against them (though not in detail). One character lies. Alcoholic beverages are served at a nightclub, and those under 21 are not permitted in a "drinking section". In the end, this is a fine choice for ages 9 and up.
